Merchants vs. Consumers: Analyzing Chargeback Winning Trends and Patterns

Get Started with a Free Quote!

Payment Solution

Please select your primary use case. This can always be changed later.

Thanks for signing up.
Please check your email inbox for next steps.
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Merchants vs. Consumers: Analyzing Chargeback Winning Trends and Patterns

Chargebacks are a significant concern for online merchants. They can be costly, time-consuming, and damaging to a business's reputation. 

As the world shifts increasingly towards digital transactions, it's becoming imperative for merchants to understand and navigate the complexities of chargeback disputes effectively. 

In this blog, we’ll discuss recent chargeback trends, provide actionable insights on how merchants can win chargeback disputes, and outline crucial patterns that could help reduce future chargeback occurrences for your business.

The Current Chargeback Landscape: Chargeback Trends You Need to Know About

In recent years, there has been a notable shift in chargeback trends, with more customers initiating disputes as they grow more familiar with the online shopping landscape. 

Here are a few stats to be aware of:

  • Chargeback rates are increasing. According to the Federal Trade Commission (FTC), there has been a notable rise in friendly fraud, where consumers make online purchases but later deny this, leading to a chargeback. This trend is particularly prevalent in digital goods and services. 
  • Chargeback fraud is on the rise. The National Retail Federation's 2020 Organized Retail Crime Survey indicates that over 60% of retailers have seen an uptick in chargeback fraud, correlating with the rise of e-commerce due to the COVID-19 pandemic. 
  • Subscription-based services are seeing more chargebacks. The rise of subscription-based services has seen a corresponding increase in chargebacks. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau reports escalating complaints from consumers unaware they were enrolled in recurring billing. 
  • Card-not-present transactions have higher chargeback rates. The Federal Reserve reports that chargeback rates are highest in sectors with a high incidence of card-not-present transactions, such as online retail and travel. This is part of the reason it’s so important to use a reputable payment provider, like Seamless Chex, to process credit card transactions
  • Chargebacks are getting more expensive. According to a study by LexisNexis, every dollar lost to chargebacks costs merchants $2.94, up from $2.77 just a year ago. 
  • Additionally, recent estimates suggest that chargeback fraud costs businesses about $20 billion annually.
  • Friendly fraud is on the rise. An estimated 86% of all chargebacks are caused by “friendly fraud” - a term used to describe consumers who, intentionally or not, misuse the chargeback process. This further exacerbates the problem for merchants, as friendly fraud is much harder to identify and dispute.

With these figures in mind, it's evident that chargebacks represent a significant challenge for online merchants. Not only do they result in immediate financial losses, but they also require time and resources to manage, contest, and - eventually - win. 

Merchants vs. Consumers: Who Usually Wins a Chargeback?

In the landscape of chargebacks, two forces are always at play: merchants and consumers. 

While consumers initiate chargebacks for various reasons – from fraudulent claims to genuine dissatisfaction with a purchase – merchants bear the brunt of these disputes, often losing revenue and incurring additional fees. 

Consumer behavior plays a significant role in the chargeback process. Some consumers may abuse the system by intentionally filing illegitimate chargebacks, while others may be unaware of the consequences of their actions. On the other hand, merchants must have robust systems and processes in place to prevent and resolve disputes effectively.

That said, the outcome of a chargeback dispute usually favors the consumer, particularly when the merchant lacks compelling evidence to validate the transaction in dispute. 

This is largely due to consumer protection laws and card network regulations that are designed to safeguard customers from fraudulent and unauthorized transactions. 

If a customer raises a chargeback, and the merchant is unable to provide adequate proof that the transaction was legitimate and the customer received the goods or services, then the customer is likely to win the chargeback.

However, this does not mean that merchants are always at a disadvantage. Merchants who employ robust chargeback management tools like those offered by Seamless Chex have a greater chance of winning chargebacks. 

These tools provide comprehensive transaction records and detail-oriented analytics, which can be critical in presenting strong evidence during dispute resolution. 

Successful dispute resolution hinges on the ability of the merchant to deliver persuasive proof of purchase, delivery, and customer acknowledgment, thereby shifting the odds in favor of the merchant. 

In the end, both consumers and merchants have a vested interest in preventing excessive chargebacks: consumers want to avoid being blacklisted by banks for fraudulent activities, while merchants strive to maintain positive relationships with their payment processors and keep their businesses afloat. 

How to Win a Chargeback: a Quick Guide for Merchants

Being on the winning side of a chargeback requires a proactive approach. 

Here are some actionable tips that merchants can use:

  1. Maintain clear and comprehensive records of transactions and customer communications.
  2. Use a recognizable name on billing statements to avoid confusion and consequent chargebacks.
  3. Have detailed and easily accessible product descriptions and images to set the right customer expectations.
  4. Implement robust verification processes for transactions to prevent fraud.
  5. Provide exemplary customer service to address and resolve issues before they escalate to chargebacks.
  6. Consider offering refunds or exchanges for dissatisfied customers to prevent chargebacks.
  7. Use fraud detection tools and services to catch fraudulent transactions before they result in chargebacks.
  8. Monitor chargeback ratios and take necessary actions to keep them within acceptable levels.
  9. Stay updated on the latest industry regulations and best practices for handling chargebacks.
  10. Consider partnering with a reliable payment processor that offers chargeback management services.

By following these tips, merchants can minimize their risk of chargebacks and increase their chances of winning them when they do occur. It is important for businesses to be proactive in preventing and managing chargebacks, as they can have a significant impact on their bottom line.

3 Factors Influencing Chargeback Outcomes

Several factors come into play when analyzing the outcomes of chargeback disputes:

  1. Customer Behavior and Dispute Resolution

Understanding customer behavior and addressing disputes promptly can positively influence the outcome of chargebacks. Active engagement and a friendly approach often lead to resolution without the need for bank intervention, which can be beneficial for both parties.

  1. Merchant Policies and Procedures

The policies and procedures that a merchant has in place can significantly impact chargeback outcomes. Clear return and refund policies, along with easy-to-follow dispute resolution guidelines, can often mitigate the need for consumers to initiate chargebacks.

  1. Fraud Prevention Measures

Investing in fraud prevention and detection systems not only helps in catching fraudulent activities but also shows the effort put in by merchants to protect their consumers, something that plays well in both customer loyalty and dispute resolution.

Seamless Chex Provides the Robust Chargeback Management Tools You Need

Robust analysis of chargeback trends and patterns is a cornerstone of a successful online merchant strategy. By better understanding the underlying causes of chargebacks, merchants can implement effective strategies to decrease their occurrence and improve dispute outcomes. 

In today’s payment landscape, merchants must continuously evolve their chargeback mitigation strategies and stay updated on the latest trends and technological advancements in fraud prevention and dispute resolution. 

That’s where Seamless Chex comes in. 

Offering a suite of robust chargeback management tools, Seamless Chex’s solutions proactively monitor transactions, analyze patterns, and identify potential threats. The advanced features of our solutions allow for early detection of fraudulent activities, thereby preventing chargebacks before they occur.

In the event of a dispute, Seamless Chex empowers merchants to win chargebacks while also maintaining high levels of customer satisfaction and safeguarding their bottom line against substantial losses.

Ready to learn more about our solutions or how they can help protect your business? Contact us today


How often do merchants win chargeback disputes?

The frequency of merchants winning chargeback disputes can vary greatly based on several factors, including the type of business, the nature of the transaction, and the quality of the evidence provided. 

While it's true that customers often have an advantage due to consumer protection laws, it's not uncommon for well-prepared merchants to win these disputes. 

Merchants using advanced chargeback management tools like Seamless Chex, which offers detailed transaction records and analytics, have been successful in contesting and winning chargeback disputes. However, it's important to note that each dispute is judged on its individual merits, and outcomes can differ from case to case.

Who is the best chargeback management company?

Seamless Chex is an industry leader in chargeback management. Serving a myriad of businesses across various sectors, we offer unparalleled service in assisting merchants to contest and win chargeback disputes.

Our platform provides comprehensive transaction records and meticulous, detail-oriented analytics. 

With these tools, merchants have direct access to crucial evidence pertaining to purchase, delivery, and customer acknowledgment, which can play a critical role in dispute resolution. 

This powerful combination of information greatly increases the likelihood of merchants building a compelling case and overturning a chargeback.

Moreover, our commitment to innovation and improvement allows us to provide better solutions for merchants, continually refining our tools to stay ahead of the curve. For these reasons and many more, Seamless Chex is the leading chargeback management company in the industry.

Will a chargeback go away on its own?

No - a chargeback will not disappear on its own. 

Once a chargeback has been filed by a customer, it is important for the merchant to respond promptly and appropriately. 

If left unaddressed, the chargeback will likely result in a loss of revenue for the merchant. It's advisable to use effective chargeback management strategies and tools, like those offered by Seamless Chex, to contest the claim and potentially reverse the chargeback.

Discover The Payment Processing Solution That's Right For Your Business

Debit bank accounts via eCheck and ACH
Sign Up
Accept Verified ACH payments and send payouts
Sign Up
Merchant Service
Accept Debit and Credit Card payments
Sign Up

Revolutionize Payment Processing Forever

Start accepting and sending customer payments today.